Do Dogs Need a Fenced Yard?

My opinion is going to make some owners and potential owners unhappy. Nevertheless, it's based on my experience, research, and common sense.

Do dogs need a fenced yard?

Yes. All dogs desire and deserve a fenced area in which to stretch their legs and run around a little, especially on dirt or grass, several times a day.

Without a fenced yard, you would need to take your dog outside on a leash even for bathroom breaks. That really isn't fair to any dog larger than a Chihuahua. Dogs don't like being tethered to a leash all the time.

It is possible, especially with a small dog, to get by with an outdoor exercise pen ("ex-pen"). This is a series of wire panels that unfold into an enclosure where your dog can romp around off-leash.

The pen in the photo is far too small, but you can buy several pens and attach them together to construct a much larger space. For example, if you type in "Midwest exercise pen" on Amazon, you could buy three of those pens to make a 12 ft by 12 ft enclosure. Four pens would make a 16 ft by 16 ft enclosure. Bigger is better!

If you live in a development with a homeowner's association, you'll need to check with them to see if they allow this. It's not permanent fencing, so they might be okay with your leaving it in place. Or they might require you to set it up and take it down each and every time you use it. That wouldn't work so well.

Any enclosure should be very, very close to your house. Remember, you will need to let your dog out multiple times a day – in bad weather, too – including very early in the morning and right before bedtime. So it needs to be close to the house.

Tethering your dog to a swivel stake or cable/pulley system

This can work if you use it ONLY so your dog has some freedom to stretch his legs and sniff around so he can do his business. Then bring him back indoors.

Never leave your dog tied outside on a tether.

Here's what can go wrong with tethers

• Tied dogs can pull the stake out of the ground or the cable off the tree.
• They can chew through the rope.
• The rope or chain can break.
• They can get tangled in the rope/chain or wind it around something and hurt themselves trying to get loose.
• Tied dogs frequently become frustrated and aggressive, barking and lunging against their restraint when anyone passes by.
• Dogs who are sensitive or anxious may feel trapped when the line becomes taut and then they might react with defensive ferocity, i.e. "I'll get YOU before you get ME!"

So, along with the physical risks and dangers of ropes and cables, tied dogs can develop unstable temperaments. Best to use these tethers sparingly and only for bathroom duties.

What if there's a dog park nearby?

You're not likely to dash to the dog park multiple times a day, especially in bad weather. There are other reasons I don't recommend taking your dog to a dog park, but that's a topic for another article. Suffice it to say that I don't recommend dog parks. Or dog beaches, for that matter.

What about "boundary training", where you teach the dog to stay in an unfenced yard?

"Boundary training" has cost countless dogs their lives. Dogs have the mentality of a 2- to 4-year-old child and can outrun an Olympic sprinter. The moment your dog is tempted over the boundary – by another dog, a squirrel, a cat – he becomes a loose dog.

Loose dogs are....

• hit by cars.
• caught in animal traps.
• injured or killed in dog fights.
• blinded by rocks pegged by bullies.
• stolen and spirited away forever.
• shot by the game warden or sheriff for running deer or livestock.
• poisoned by irate neighbors for pooping on their lawn.

Loose dogs also cause accidents. Have you ever swerved sharply to avoid someone else's dog dashing across the street? If by good fortune there wasn't a car coming in the opposite direction, there may be next time.

What about electronic or invisible fencing?

Many homeowners' associations today don't allow you to put up a fenced yard. This is a disastrous policy for those of us who are responsible dog owners.

Some associations allow you to install an invisible or electronic fence. You might be wondering, "Does an invisible fence work for dogs? Is it safe?"

An invisible/electronic fence is a wire cable that you run underground, all around the perimeter of your property. The wire has a digital radio frequency running through it. If your dog, wearing a special collar, approaches the wire, his collar picks up the radio frequency and emits a warning sound. If the dog keeps going, he receives an electrical shock.

I don't recommend these "fences". In my experience, they are neither safe nor secure.

Risks of an invisible/electronic fence

• If the motivation is strong enough – say, another dog running past, or a squirrel or cat, even thunder or fireworks – some dogs will dash right across the electrical wire and take the shock, just to get out.
• With nothing to block their view, dogs "confined" by an invisible fence often bark more. They may also charge toward anything they can see, including your neighbors minding their own business in their own yard. If the charging dog gets too close to the line, the resulting shock may be mis-associated with your neighbor  and now the dog may develop a phobic fear or aggression toward that person.
• Your dog is completely open to attack by loose dogs passing by. This is especially scary if your own dog is small. This threat alone is enough for me to turn thumbs-down on invisible fencing. A major purpose for fencing is to protect  your own dog.
• Finally, you're wrapping electronics around your dog's neck and hoping it works perfectly. But we all know that electronics can be buggy. A defective/malfunctioning collar could repeatedly shock your dog and turn him into a neurotic wreck.

Summary: I hope you will confine your dog safely and effectively within a physical fence.